June 2016 Update

5 years ago I made the decision to become a watchmaker.

It was a completely unexpected result of seaching for a new career, and it has been a very interesting journey. I’ve written about the story of becoming a watchmaker here.

Anyway, some news. Firstly I’m writing articles again now after an extended break. The main reason for the hiatus was that I was still studying for the final part of my BHI exams in 2015. That has now finished – as I will explain later – and so I have more free time.

Writing articles for this website can take a very long time; sometimes in excess of 40 hours per piece. From a purely selfish point of view there has been no real benefit to the site for me; it’s not helped me find work or otherwise made any money, and in fact there have been some very negative effects from putting things into the public domain. But it has offered me the opportunity to help encourage people into the industry, and it is also acts as a journal of my career – and it can be very nice to look back on how different life was, even just a few years ago.

Some weeks I have half a dozen people write to ask advice. If I’m busy I can take a week or so to reply, but I do always reply. I’d say more than half of the people don’t write to say thank-you afterwards, even although many of the replies can take me quite a while to put together; particularly if there’s research involved. It’s a bit frustrating, but as with writing articles, I don’t do it for personal reward but rather will gain satisfaction from the occasional time someone decides to make the same bold step I took those 5 years ago.

________________________________

I also was featured in the December 2015 Horological Journal, which was really nice. It was part of a feature about students that won awards.

bhi-article2

Part of an article from the December 2016 Horological Journal highlighting students that had won awards that year

Below is the text from the article:

How did you become interested in horology?

“I returned to the UK in 2010, after having spent the past 8 years in China and decided that I needed to choose a career and specialise in something. I went to the local library and looked at books on absolutely everything; from landscape gardening, to being a doctor, even a masseuse. One of the books I was left with was about watch repair. It hadn’t even occurred to me that this could be a job, perhaps because I’d never owned a watch worth repairing. But the more I looked into it; learning about the history, the characters, the innovation and the craft of watchmaking, the more I was drawn in, and the more it felt as if this was something that suited my character and skills. Sometimes I still think about my other life as a masseur though!”

What has been the best part of your continued education at the BHI?

“Learning what you can achieve, and that you can always surprise yourself. In my whole life I’d never made anything with my hands before and so turning what looks like pieces of scrap metal into useful tools feels like you have magical powers! Every day at work I use at least half a dozen items that I’ve crafted by hand, and although I can still gaze in wonder at what others can create, I now have the confidence to say that given enough time – I could make that too. Such a change from just a few years ago where everything would have looked impossible, and only achievable by someone far more gifted than I could ever hope to be.”

What advice do you have for prospective horology students or people wanting to learn more about horology?

“Realise that it starts as a level playing field, and that no-one has “natural” talent. What may seem as someone being gifted is the result of a whole lot of passion, dedication, commitment and hard work. If you want to make watches like George Daniels did, then the only thing stopping you, is you. It is no coincidence that the most successful people in horology are also the hardest working. Also, be aware that watchmaking is a tiny industry and watchmakers love to gossip, which means reputations can grow and shatter very quickly. So be nice!”

What are your hopes and dreams for your future in the world of horology?

“I know that I will never stop learning, and it is very exciting to think about the future. Beyond finishing the additional modules to get my FBHI title, I aim to create my own watch. I have started and made some progress already, and hopefully I can use that as a starting block to work towards making a small contribution to the British watchmaking industry. It was one of the original appeals of watchmaking, that one person can make a real difference, and I think it is still true. Work hard, aim high and who knows?”

________________________________

It’s really nice to receive recognition for hard work. I’ve had a lot of support over the years, and I’m very grateful for it all.

Another piece of news is the fact that I’m not studying anymore; despite what the last paragraph of my interview says.

As mentioned I had planned to take the two extra units and complete the exams to gain a Fellowship with the BHI (FBHI). These steps are highlighted in the below image.

bhi-course

The detail from the BHI’s literature that clearly shows the route to attaining MBHI and FBHI

Having already spent about £1000 and hundreds of hours on my restoration portfolio, the BHI decided to arbitrarily take away the award for students. Sadly this has meant all the expended time and money was in effect wasted.

You could still gain the higher level 5 qualification, but unfortunately no-one in the industry really knows the newer exam structure. Watchmaking is very much a meritocracy; based on what you are capable of. So without a fellowship attached to the qualification, which I saw as being the closest thing to calling yourself a Doctor, it became (for me at least) pointless.

The saddest part about this was how I found out about this, which was by accident. After being told of the decision casually in passing by another student I contacted the BHI for clarifcation. I was told that the BHI education board had decided to make the change, and not tell any students. They had decided that giving the FBHI title to students was too generous; even although we’d been told that as fact for the past 3/4 years.

Historically the fellowship had been awarded to students for just passing the main exams – which I have already done.

Throughout my studies I’ve been bombarded with negative comments concerning the BHI, and I’ve always defended them. Myself and other students felt that allowing students to reach the highest tier was was a change in the attitiude in the BHI and a realisation that the rapidly aging membership needed to attract and keep younger talent.

I’m not going to lie, this may have had an irreconcilable effect on my longterm opinion of the BHI. I did consider not renewing my membership, but decided to not react with emotion and to see if by next year time would had tempered my perspective.

________________________________

Finally, in July I’ll have my first apprentice to train which I am very enthused about. Being able to pass on what I’ve learnt is one of the most rewarding parts of any job. Let’s hope that it goes really well and there are many more talented young people to follow.

5 Responses

  1. david pierce says:

    Colin,
    Not to worry. The old guard is still trying to stick to 19th century solutions in the 21st century. This website you started will give you plenty of credibility and respect. The younger generation that will soon take over the decision making positions around the world is less impressed with credentials and far more impressed with the ability to do the job correctly. With the advent the internet and particularly Youtube, a person’s accomplishments can be seen by others and an assessment of that person’s abilities can be made more accurately than looking at an impressive title. George Daniels had numerous titles and credentials but had he not been able to produce the George Daniels Watches, nobody ever would have heard of him. If you run through Youtube and watch the videos produced by Steffen Pahlow, Vianney Halter, Philipe Defour, Gray & Sons Jewelers, The Watch Repair Channel, etc. who cares if they do or do not have a fellowship with the BHI. This is becoming a bottom line world and the bottom line is, these people do great work.
    david

    • Colin Colin says:

      Hi David,

      Thank you very much for your message. I think you’ve put it very well. George Daniels was not a fan, and left them no money from his huge estate.

      For me most of the disapointment was that I had set my sights on something from the 1st day I started training to become a watchmaker, and then the goal-posts hadn’t moved, they’d disapeared completely. So I guess it’s the feeling of an anti-climax.

      The salt was rubbed in slightly due to the person telling me I couldn’t become a fellow – because that title was only reserved for the most experienced people who had made a large contribution to horology – was made a fellow. That’s despite having no experience in horology, and their contribution being limited to doing their paid-for managerial job for 2 years. Sigh.

      I suppose the greatest disapointment came from the realisation that the BHI hadn’t changed. It seemed as if it was moving in a more modern direction, and learning the mistakes of the past. Of opening up and doing away with the “old boy network”. But as I wrote about here: http://great-british-watch.co.uk/the-british-watch-and-clockmaking-company/, the BHI actually helped destroy the remaining British watch industry 150 years ago – by simply blocking any attempt to modernise. (Although perhaps their true impact is only noticable with hindsight).

      It’s a shame, but it fortunately won’t directly impact me. Their main training course remains excellent though, as do their short courses.

      Colin

  2. david pierce says:

    Colin,
    Let me put it this way. Suppose you had a rare watch that had been in your family for several generations. The watch was no longer running due to missing gear teeth, broken pivots, broken mainspring etc. If you knew little about watches, at that time, and were unable to restore the watch yourself, who would you have preferred to send it to for a complete restoration. Would you had preferred to send it to Steffen Pahlow or the two year manager with the impressive BHI title. Now that you have those skills and can do the restoration yourself, which of those two do you respect as a watchmaker.
    david

  3. Roland says:

    Colin, there are still people out there who do appreciate the old hand-craft and skills. To be sure, these “old-fashion” skills have had a big dent due to all the mass production of cheap stuff. Nonetheless, I like to think that the number of people who start to re-appreciate these old skills / hand-craft is growing. Times are changing faster than ever and adaptation is required. New marketing skills to reach the group who is searching for the few (often hidden) “needles” left. Just as impressed I’m with your achievements, I’m also impressed with Mark Lovick’s YouTube Watch Repair Channel. Mark has stepped into the limelight and his Watch Repair Talk forum is growing fast. I guess he is well known by now and perhaps it pays off for him. I sincerely hope you pursuit your dreams and yes, you do have fans, me for one 😉 A BIG thank you !!
    Wishing you all the best wishes, a healthy and prosperous 2017.

    Roland, Denmark.

    • Colin Colin says:

      Thanks a lot Roland, it’s very encouraging to hear that from you!

      I’d not seen Mark’s channel before, so I’ll have to take at look at some of his work. I’m training an apprentice at the moment and I’m taking notes of some of the things that I’m showing him. So I hope to be able to share some of these in the future. I had also been thinking about making some videos for a while now, and so after I move home in the New Year then this is something I may consider doing.

      I wish you a happy 2017 too!

      Cheers

      Colin

Leave a Reply


*